For each proposal presented in class, each group is responsible for developing one well considered critique based on the written and oral proposals. The groups receiving the critiques will also evaluate the importance of your critiques, so spend some time thinking about what needs to be said.

Project proposal referee report

Reviewer's name:
Reviewer's e-mail:
Project name:
Project authors: Overall Rating: For each of these criteria, rate the proposal as "excellent", "good", "fair", or "poor". Feel free to add comments below.
Significance ______
Quality of Plan ______
Overall Rating ______

Should this proposal be nominated for the "best proposal" award?