Matt Kaufmann, ACL2 seminar, 8/4/04: Small vs. large images. Large image advantages: Verify-termination on system functions, :doc in loop. Statistics below are for Debian Gnu Linux. ====================================================================== Allegro CL: Approximate 4.9% speedup, 59% image growth. make-regression-jul31-04-allegro-small.log: 11931.590u 140.430s 3:29:24.01 96.0% 0+0k 0+0io 9718511pf+0w make-regression-jul31-04-allegro-large.log: 11369.070u 141.610s 3:19:37.46 96.1% 0+0k 0+0io 8983236pf+0w 16867328 Jul 31 23:48 /projects/acl2/v2-9/allegro-saved_acl2.dxl 26861568 Jul 31 15:52 /projects/acl2/v2-9/allegro-large-saved_acl2.dxl ====================================================================== GCL 2.6.3 (no SGC): Approximate 3.6% slowdown, 12% image growth. make-regression-jul31-04-gcl-small.log: 7683.820u 178.340s 2:17:06.54 95.5% 0+0k 0+0io 12734208pf+0w make-regression-jul31-04-gcl-large.log: 7971.570u 173.370s 2:20:59.86 96.2% 0+0k 0+0io 13455763pf+0w 40596672 Aug 1 07:26 /projects/acl2/v2-9/linux-gcl-saved_acl2.gcl 45421760 Aug 1 11:57 /projects/acl2/v2-9/linux-gcl-large-saved_acl2.gcl ====================================================================== GCL 2.6.4pre (SGC): Approximate 1.4% slowdown, 26% image growth. make-regression-jul31-04-gcl-2.6.4pre-small.log: 7750.700u 174.560s 2:17:20.00 96.1% 0+0k 0+0io 12742495pf+0w make-regression-jul31-04-gcl-2.6.4pre-large.log: 7856.270u 182.790s 2:19:03.05 96.3% 0+0k 0+0io 14345776pf+0w 46234865 Aug 1 23:42 /projects/acl2/v2-9/linux-gcl-2.6.4pre-small-saved_acl2.gcl 58219761 Aug 1 20:18 /projects/acl2/v2-9/linux-gcl-2.6.4pre-large-saved_acl2.gcl ====================================================================== OpenMCL: Approximate 10.7% slowdown, 48% image growth. make-regression.log: real 511m9.531s user 483m31.580s sys 28m21.530s make-regression-large.log: .... real 568m46.501s user 534m21.490s sys 32m35.340s 17563424 6 Jun 17:42 saved_acl2.dppccl 26073312 2 Aug 11:43 large-saved_acl2.dppccl ====================================================================== CMUCL: Approximate 2.6% slowdown, 23% image growth. make-regression-jul31-04-cmucl-small.log: 11081.210u 259.930s 3:25:37.99 91.9% 0+0k 0+0io 8840687pf+0w make-regression-jul31-04-cmucl-large.log: 11372.140u 261.300s 3:29:01.75 92.7% 0+0k 0+0io 10121698pf+0w 37883904 Aug 2 11:49 /projects/acl2/v2-9/cmucl-saved_acl2.core 46608384 Aug 2 23:27 /projects/acl2/v2-9/cmucl-large-saved_acl2.core ======================================================================