This simple Javascript calculator determines long-term, steady-state average dps for a paladin. Choose a premade suit and weapon from the drop-down list or provide your own stats. Visit http://ctprofiles.net/3801056 to see what each suit includes. The Cleaver is added to those suits to give the correct value for crit without affecting other non-weapon-specific stats.
When making the suits, I filled in the remaining slots with DPS items that I considered easily acquired by that gear level. The "My Gear" selection is the gear that I, as a very new 60, am currently wearing, and consists primarily of pre-tier 0 gear.
To have Judgement of the Crusader up for the duration of the test, enter the Holy damage increase of your JotC in the Holy Damage box. Untalented without the PvP gloves or the libram, this is 140.