next up previous
Next: Acknowledgements Up: The CMUnited-97 Small Robot Previous: The Goalkeeper

Discussion and Conclusion


CMUnited-97 successfully demonstrated the feasibility and effectiveness of teams of multiagent robotic systems. Within this paradigm, one of the major challenges was to ``close the loop,'' i.e., to integrate all the different modules, ranging from perception to strategic multiagent reasoning. CMUnited is an example of a fully implemented multiagent system in which the loop is closed. In addition, we implemented interesting strategic behaviors, including agent collaboration and real-time evaluation of alternative actions.

It is generally very difficult to accumulate significant scientific results to test teams of robots. Realistically, extended runs are prohibited by battery limitations and the difficulty of keeping many robots operational concurrently. Furthermore, we only had the resources to build a single team of five robots, with one spare so far. Therefore, we offer a restricted evaluation of CMUnited based on the results of four effective 10-minute games that were played at RoboCup-97. We also include anecdotal evidence of the multiagent capabilities of the CMUnited-97 robotic soccer team. Table 1 shows the results of the games at RoboCup-97.

Table 1: The scores of CMUnited's games in the small robot league of RoboCup-97. CMUnited-97 won all four games.

In total, CMUnited-97 scored thirteen goals, allowing only one against. The one goal against was scored by the CMUnited goalkeeper against itself, though under an attacking situation from France. We refined the goalkeeper's goal behavior, as presented in this paper, following the observation of our goalkeeper's error.

As the matches proceeded, spectators noticed many of the team behaviors described in the paper. The robots switched positions during the games, and there were several successful passes. The most impressive goal of the tournament was the result of a 4-way passing play: one robot 1 passed to a second robot 2, which passed back to robot 1; then robot 1 passed to a third robot 3, which shot the ball into the goal.

In general, the robots' behaviors were visually appealing and entertaining to the spectators. Several people attained a first-hand appreciation for the difficulty of the task as we let them try controlling a single robot with a joystick program that we developed. All of these people (several children and a few adults) found it quite difficult to maneuver a single robot well enough to direct a ball into an open goal. These people in particular were impressed with the facility with which the robots were able to autonomously pass, score, and defend.

We are aware that many issues are clearly open for further research and development. We are currently systematically identifying them and addressing them towards our next team version. In particular, we are planning on enhancing the robot's behaviors by using machine learning techniques. We are currently developing techniques to accumulate and analyze real robot data.

next up previous
Next: Acknowledgements Up: The CMUnited-97 Small Robot Previous: The Goalkeeper

Peter Stone
Sun Dec 7 06:55:46 EST 1997